Insurance · Pricing · 2026
Trustee indemnity insurance cost in 2026: real prices, real drivers, and why bundling beats standalone
What trustee indemnity actually costs this year — drawn from the only providers that publish prices openly, with the framework for what drives the number up or down for your specific charity.
Last updated 16 May 2026·9 min read
Some links below earn us a commission if you buy a policy. We don't recommend products we wouldn't suggest to a trustee in our own family — see our affiliate disclosure.
What you'll actually pay — the bands
Almost every TII price you'll see in the wild is bundled with at least one other cover. Standalone TII is rare in this market because brokers know charities need the package. The bands below combine genuinely published prices (Markel, Zurich, Get Indemnity) with broker-channel norms for the larger end.
Very small community group / CIC
From £36 / year
Markel Direct: bundled PI + trustees' liability, sub-£10k turnover, £500k limit.
Small charity package (sub-£100k income)
£56–£500 / year
Zurich Charity package from £56; trustee indemnity uplift adds £20–£200 depending on limit.
Standalone trustee indemnity
From £198 / year
Get Indemnity via WTW network, £100k–£500k limit. The published transparency benchmark.
Mid-sized incorporated charity
£500–£2,000 / year
£1m+ limit · regulatory investigation defence · six-year run-off · advice/safeguarding activity.
Two charities with identical income can be £300 apart depending on activity profile, claims history, and governance documentation. The figures above are guides — your real number is the rated calculation across the variables below.
What drives the number up — 8 factors
Annual income or turnover
The single biggest variable. £25k-income charities pay materially less than £200k-income ones. Bands typically step at £50k, £100k, £250k, £500k.
Number of trustees / directors
More heads to potentially defend. Most policies are issued in the charity's name covering all current trustees; rating typically allows up to 12 before stepping up.
Activity risk profile
Working with children or vulnerable adults loads the rating. Same for advocacy, debt advice, immigration advice, regulated counselling.
Prior claims history
A previous Charity Commission investigation, a defended claim, or an ICO data-protection penalty all shift the rating band — sometimes substantially.
Governance quality
Up-to-date accounts, annual return filed on time, clear governing document, regular trustee meetings minuted. Insurers ask. Soft underwriting penalty if absent.
Structure
Unincorporated bodies pay a premium relative to CIOs and charitable companies for equivalent income — joint and several liability and the unincorporated contract exposure both push the number up.
Reserve levels
Insurers became materially more interested in reserve adequacy after Kids Company. Low reserves relative to commitments now affect underwriting acceptance, not just price.
Limit of indemnity chosen
£250k → £500k typically adds 30–50% to the premium. £500k → £1m adds another 50–80%. The right limit is the one matched to your activity profile, not the highest you can stomach.
What drives the number down — 5 levers
Bundle with PL, EL, PI
TII as a section of a charity package policy (Zurich, Ansvar, PolicyBee, Markel) is almost always cheaper than standalone. Get Indemnity's standalone £198/year is the benchmark; bundled equivalents typically run £75–£150.
Lower limit (where proportionate)
A £250k limit for a small grant-funded charity with no paid staff is often sufficient — and 30–50% cheaper than the £500k default.
Multi-year (long-term agreement)
Several insurers offer 5–15% off a three-year LTA. Worth it where activity and structure are stable; not worth it if you're considering incorporation.
Clean claims history
A clean five-year record at the small-charity end can unlock 5–10% off and access to better wordings.
Documented governance
Some insurers (PolicyBee, Markel) offer modest discounts for documented evidence of governance (annual return filed, accounts on time, safeguarding policy in force).
How to push back at renewal
- Confirm the limit is right.If your activity, income or asset base hasn't changed, the limit shouldn't need to rise. A flat renewal at the same limit is the correct baseline.
- Get one bundled benchmark quote. PolicyBee or Markel Direct, identical limit and activity declarations. Use it to test the renewal, not necessarily to switch.
- Document what hasn't happened. No Charity Commission contact, no ICO penalty, no defended claim, no resignations — say so. Underwriters reward visible stability.
- Test the LTA discount.A 3-year commitment can save 5–15% if activity is stable. Avoid the lock-in if you're considering incorporation or restructuring.
- Reduce the limit if proportionate. A small grant-funded charity rarely needs £1m+ of TII. £250k–£500k is often the honest answer — and meaningfully cheaper.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the £3/month headline price not what we'll pay?+
Markel Direct's £3/month is for the smallest profile — a community group or CIC with around £10k turnover buying a combined PI + trustees' liability bundle at £500k limit. Most actual charities sit above that profile. £75–£200 / year is the typical bundled price band for a small charity; £250–£500 for mid-sized; £500–£2,000+ for larger or higher-risk profiles.
Why is standalone TII so much more expensive than bundled?+
Underwriting and administration costs are a higher proportion of a small standalone premium than of a bundled one. Brokers know charities mostly need the package and price the bundle accordingly. Standalone TII at Get Indemnity (£198/year) is the cleanest published benchmark, but if you're also buying PL and PI elsewhere, bundling those three at PolicyBee or Markel usually beats the standalone+separate model on total spend.
Has TII pricing risen in the hard market?+
Less than other lines. Charity-sector TII has been described by brokers (PolicyBee, Get Indemnity) as 'soft-to-flat' across 2023–2025 while commercial D&O has hardened. No public index supports a precise trend line — but anecdotally, trustees re-quoting at renewal have seen 0–5% movement most years, with bigger jumps reserved for genuine claim or activity changes.
Should we pay this from charity funds?+
Yes, under s.189 Charities Act 2011 — provided the four CC49 conditions are met (governing document doesn't forbid; premium is reasonable; wording excludes the statutorily prohibited indemnities; trustees are satisfied it serves the charity's interests). Record the decision in the minutes. Equivalent powers exist in Scotland (s.68A Charities and Trustee Investment Act 2005) and Northern Ireland (Charities Act NI 2008).
What's the cheapest legitimate way to get cover?+
If you're under £100k income and need PL + TII together: Zurich Charity's £56/year package with the TII uplift, or Markel Direct's bundled product from £36/year. If you're a registered Scout group: Unity Insurance Services (Scout-funded, free at point of use). Anything below those numbers is either an entry profile that probably doesn't match yours, or a wording with a limit too low to actually do the job.
Related guides
Trustee indemnity insurance: do you actually need it? →
The decision aid before the price discussion — when TII is proportionate, when it isn't.
Best trustee indemnity insurance: six providers compared →
The realistic shortlist with strengths, watch-outs, and who each one is for.
What trustee indemnity actually covers →
Section by section, including the exclusion list trustees keep missing.
Legal structures for UK community groups →
Why incorporation often beats insurance as the first move.
Village hall insurance cost in 2026 →
If you're a village-hall trustee, TII is usually bundled in the package — see real cost bands here.
Sources
Published price points: Markel Direct, Zurich Charity, Get Indemnity (WTW), Ecclesiastical (broker-only); broker commentary (PolicyBee, Get Indemnity, Anderson Strathern, Russell-Cooke); Charity Commission CC49; Charities Act 2011 s.189; Charity Finance Group; Civil Society reporting (including coverage of Kids Company defence costs); Bates Wells charity briefings; Stone King trustee guidance.